Universities and Student Protests: Too Much Blood

Sri Lanka has a lot of protests, most of them conducted by local universities. We protest everything – governments,  private education, scholarships, private education, private education… you get the picture. It seems that every other month there’s a couple of metal barricades and one of them water cannon machines rolling up the road.

I’ve had the unfortunate experience of being caught up in a couple of these, and the level of thought gone into these is incredible. Mindless chanters – check. Coerced students – check. Placards. Banners onna stick.  Firebrands strung at strategic intervals to make sure everyone’s equally involved. There are always university students who, for fear of ragging, temporarily take up the robes of a Buddhist monk: these are generally placed front and center. Give it a couple more years and we’ll have enough expertise to launch a B.A. in Professional Protesting.

Usually it stops there. Usually people block traffic for a while, or sit on a pavement outside the Colombo Fort Railway Station, and usually bemused-looking cops hang back and hope nobody does anything foolish. Then everybody goes away.

This time, the excrement made physical contact with the electrically powered oscillating air current distribution device.

Let me now say the obvious thing that everybody expects you to say: this was wrong, those cops should be arrested, etcetera, etcetera, students, innocent, people getting people, blood, etcetera.

At the same time, it is  inevitable. Policemen are humans, and humans are not known for rational action. We go overboard. We do cruel things to one another. Perhaps there was one cop who had seen too many protests and had too many stones thrown at them. Perhaps Han shot first. This isn’t an excuse, but this is expected.

Now pull back a bit. This is not an isolated case. Why are students protesting? Why are there always students protesting? 

One reason: it’s too easy to protest.

Think about it. You have an idea. Say it’s something as stupid as wanting the government to guarantee jobs (er – why? If you can’t get a job, it’s not the government’s fault – pick something people want to hire you for, you moron!). Or say it’s something intelligent, like the disgusting standards of university accommodation.

Nobody listens. This is a blanket ban: smart ideas are rejected as equally as the stupid ones.

What do you do? Contact the Inter University Student Federation. The IUSF are the JVP lapdogs: by all accounts they’re what you get when you mix communism, clever rhetoric rage and popular idiocy together. These are the rednecks of Sri Lanka. They will, at the drop of a red cap, drum up a multi-university mob and hit the streets.

Now onward! You obviously don’t disperse when told to – who does that? So you wait until the vehicles are jammed for miles behind you and the police roll out the rubber bullets and the water cannons. The next day, assuming you’re not getting your beauty sleep in hospital and bitterly cursing your JVP overlords, you’re back in university, swapping tales and planning the next one.

Notice the people with the scripts in hand.

Is our system this bad? Not necessarily. Our system isn’t perfect, but look: we have free education.  Have you tried earning a degree in this country if you can’t get those three A’s for university? I have. It’s insanely expensive – you’re literally talking millions of rupees. Only a very small minority of very privileged children fit the “white-boy-coasting-on-rich-parents’-money” stereotype that applies when you say “private degree”: the majority of students have to scrap around, take loans, get themselves into colossal debt, and then work their rear ends off for quite a while before they’re out of debt.

This is the alternative. Trust me: you have it good.

Many of us look upon these protests with envy and a sort of amused sense of WTF. Envy, because some people actually have the time to protest, and WTF, because most of these protests are just flat-out stupid. Increase a scholarship by 2000 rupees? For fuck’s sake, find a side job. Freelance. If you have the time to be rioting, you have the time to be a productive human being and make that 2000 bucks and then some.

And this is funny, because Sri Lanka is cheap. In the US, or the UK, or developed countries where there is no free lunch, it’s common to spend your late twenties just working to pay the rent on a crummy apartment and pay off those student loans. We have it nice, really. Our parents have houses. Ammi cooks the rice (or that’s the norm). Most people only need to get out and be functioning adults after they get married – and even then you’re subsidized. And of course, nobody pays taxes.

Where we go wrong is this leeway. There’s too much of it. Educations are delivered free: no penalties. You’re allowed to protest education; you’re allowed to riot for the lack of education; you’re allowed to, and I’m not making this up, protest for people who were arrested on charges of ragging students. And we just sit back and dismiss this.

University students will be university students, eh?

We have become too used to this, I tell you: too jaded.

Every month the banners go up. Every month some hapless policeman must call up his wife, promise to get home for dinner, then don the helmet and go out into the streets. Every month, we share pictures, we make noises of outrage. Activists hashtag stuff. Someone cleverly blames it on whoever is running the government at the time. And then we go back to our lives.

Nobody fixes the problems. Nobody gives a fuck. All that happens is a bunch of students get used as cannon fodder, a couple of policemen are carted off to disciplinary hearings, and the world goes back to what it was. Does it matter whether universities are letting themselves be politically exploited ? Who cares? Some men just want to watch students burn.

While people bleed, the anti-government rhetoric goes up, some of it terribly written.

While people bleed, the anti-government rhetoric goes up. I’m no Hemmingway myself, but some of this stuff is genuinely bad writing.

What do we do to fix this? First, we arrest those policemen. Then we arrest those protesters. Then we arrest the organizers. While they’re beating the crap out of each other in a jail cell, we need to seriously address the issue of fixing things. Someone needs to get the Ministers of Education and their motley crew to go over each and every complaint, see if it’s reasonable, and implement it – or denounce it. And the next time a protest happens for something stupid, those protesters need to be kicked out of university. No buts, no temporary suspensions. There are a thousand others waiting to take their place.

If someone wants to riot, they better believe in it: believe in it to the point where they’re willing to sacrifice their educations and future careers for it. This is real life. You shouldn’t get to disturb a whole city and then get back to your dream of a white picket fence, three kids and a pension.  If you want to Disturb the Peace, it better be for a very, very good cause.


 

Regarding the recent protest:  the clash reportedly injured eight people – including four female students and a police constable. The injured have been admitted to the Colombo National Hospital. The police arrested 39 students: five female students and two monks were among the arrested, said the police. For what it’s worth, I’m glad that they’re not discriminating and letting the monks go. 

8 thoughts on “Universities and Student Protests: Too Much Blood”

  1. well lot of issues you are addressing here. Not sure I will be able to cover them all but here goes nothing.

    IUSF is not a JVP lapdog (not anymore). They now belong to the Frontline Socialist Party (peratugami samajavadi pakshaya) and if you don’t know what that is, it’s Kumar Gunarathnam’s party (other party members include most of the former IUSF leaders such as Udul Premarathna).

    “Is our system this bad? Not necessarily. ”

    Our system is more screwed up than you can ever imagine and it seems to be getting even more with time. Now let me elaborate.

    Sri Lankan school education system has a huge problem. It is very weak on science and maths. Large number of students fail these subjects at O/L and A/Ls. So the obvious (to most) answer should be a good plan to solve this problem (more teachers, quality of the teachers). But instead of that, SL government has coming up with schemes so that students will be able to sort of “by pass” O/L and A/L math and science barriers.

    Sri Lankan Government University system has a huge problem because they take-in a very un-necessary number of Arts (Colombo uni takes 550, J’pura 675, Kalaniya 1200, Peradenia 600, etc.) and Management students (Colombo uni takes 420, J’pura 910, Kalaniya 350, Peradenia 150, etc.) .Instead of cutting this down (which is going to be very controversial, will be opposed by both students and university staff), government is busy pumping money in to art faculties in the hope that somehow they would “improve” and the students will be “employable”. In the end these students ends up in government jobs. The story is similar in science faculties. They produce thousands of Science graduates (chemistry, physics, maths, etc.) and SL simply does not have enough jobs in these fields.

    By contrast they only produce 1240 Doctors, 1510 Engineers (out of that less than 300 Computer Engineers.), 360 Computer Science graduates (I assume. There may be others I have missed), Another few hundred IT, SE and IS graduates. Even if you count students who do IT/CS as a major component in their degrees, it want be able to counter the number of Arts students. But when you consider major industries in SL like tourism (and hotels) and Software Development, you will see that most university degrees don’t really address the job market. And those degrees consume the (very limited available) resources which might be better spent somewhere else.

    And instead of directly confronting the issues SL government is introducing schemes like the new A/L technology stream. While in theory it does not sound like a bad idea, in practice it may create a huge clusterfu#k in the future when these people enter the universities (They will study four academic years in the university but their degree will be only equivalent to a normal three year degree). And that is going to be a problem. BTW the students who got beat up yesterday were protesting demanding a degree equivalent recognition for their Higher national diploma (HND).

    1. Yudhanjaya Wijeratne

      Supply and demand, aka. There’s a lot of students who go for Arts. This may also be because the school system overwhelmingly puts underperformers into the Arts section. This in turn generates backlash when the govt tries to cut down the arts.
      Someone should inject a dose of reality into students and show them how job markets really work/
      Agreed on the mismatch between what’s taught and what’s relevant to the industry.

      1. Yudhanjaya,
        it’s not supply and demand in the broad picture. It’s more of a “trend” or “how the river flows”.

        And if there are that many under performers, Sri Lankans must be a genetically stupid group of humans. However, I think the cause is problems with the school system. Specially the the number of science/ maths teachers and the quality of the teachers.

        And that “dose of reality” also needs to be put in there by the Government through the education system. But even if students get that “dose of reality”, it is not the students who create policy, determine the number of positions in degree programs, etc..

        And also it’s not really what is being taught, it is the number of students who get taught. I’m not calling for Arts streams to be abolished, but I’m calling for gradual decrease in the number of students who get enrolled in.

        And BTW it is not only only students would protest cuts in arts stream. Suggest this to faculty and you would see the reaction. Suggest this to FUTA and see their reaction and you can then decide on who shares to bigger blame.

        1. Yudhanjaya Wijeratne

          It’s not a river, either – it’s a cycle. There are students, so policy is made. Because bad policy is made, there are more students. And of course the teachers would also protest: they need jobs, too.

          1. Yudhanjaya,
            I’m not saying Students are not a stakeholders in this issue.

            But what I’m saying is you are overestimating their (students) leverage. Probably because they and what they do is very visible (like above). But you know, these kind of policy is rarely made on whims of students.

            And it’s not about lecturers loosing their jobs. It’s more of “turf” thing.

  2. Excellent article Yudhanjaya. Poverty did not cause this. Poverty mentality did. ” I deserve free things, i’m entitled for xy because I’m z, i can’t get from A to B because X won’t help me”. I was born into a lower middle class family. And i went to school at a public college. Never did i blame the government for my problems or expect them to elevate my quality of life. My life is my own responsibility. The idea that the government is supposed knock on your door and greet you with job offers is so ridiculous. Someone needs to teach these people that there is something called job searching in this world. Go network, make some connections, improve your social skills, find some vacancies and apply. Couldn’t get through? Fine try again. Can’t seem to get in? Learn a different trade and try again!!!

    1. Yudhanjaya Wijeratne

      If only more people got this. I feel that as a nation we’ve been spoiled by too many things given free. It’s not as if we even pay ~50% income tax, as in Sweden.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.